New Mexico Man Charged After Alleged Escape, Jail Altercation in Custer County

The Penny News 1669

Arapaho, OK – A New Mexico man faces two felony charges and a misdemeanor following an alleged escape from custody and an altercation at the Custer County Jail.

Elvis Johnathan Toledo, 45, of Pueblo, New Mexico, was charged in Custer County District Court with two counts of assault and battery on a police officer and one count of escape from arrest or detention.

According to a probable cause affidavit, Toledo was being transported from the Custer County Jail to a Clinton hospital for medical treatment on September 22. Authorities allege that while at the hospital, Toledo got up and ran from the emergency room.

A detention officer pursued Toledo and ordered him to stop, according to the affidavit. Toledo was reportedly caught near South 28th Street and Custer Avenue in Clinton and taken back into custody.

The affidavit states that after Toledo was returned to the Custer County Jail, an altercation occurred while detention officers were processing him. Authorities allege Toledo attempted to punch and headbutt one detention officer before striking that officer in the head. Toledo is also accused of punching a second detention officer in the face as officers attempted to restrain him.

Officers eventually took Toledo to the ground and placed him in handcuffs, according to the affidavit.

Prosecutors filed the case September 28. Each felony assault and battery charge carries a possible punishment of up to five years in prison, a fine of up to $500, or both. The misdemeanor escape charge carries a possible punishment of up to two years in jail, a fine of up to $1,000, or both.

The charges are allegations. Toledo is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court.

Copyright 2026 Paragon Communications. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.


 
 

More News

Sports
The Penny News 1900
Sports | November 20, 2026
High School Football & Basketball plus College Football & Thunder Weekends
Podcasts
The Penny News 1897
Podcasts | November 20, 2026
Tune in to Today in Ag with Jimmy Clark, airing every weekday at noon on KECO 96.5 FM. Recorded November 20, 2026.
News
The Penny News 1898
News | November 20, 2026
Mayor Micah Kilhoffer and State Rep. Nick Archer say the proposed development could bring major economic opportunities to western Oklahoma, but several hurdles remain.
Podcasts
The Penny News 1896
Podcasts | November 20, 2026
The Exploring Energy Radio Show with Shawn Wilson airs every weekday at 8:00 AM on KECO 96.5 FM. Recorded November 20, 2026. Nick Archer, Oklahoma State Representative, District 55 (R) is our Featured Guest Today on the EE!
Podcasts
The Penny News 1895
Podcasts | November 20, 2026
The Early Morning Show with Nathan and Landry Brewer airs every weekday at 7:00 AM on KECO 96.5 FM. Recorded November 20, 2026.
Weather
The Penny News 1894
Weather | November 19, 2026
Oklahoma summary from the National Drought Summary for November 17, 2026 / South.

 
PN49246
HOLIDAY DEADLINE — The Penny News office will be closed Thursday & Friday, Nov. 26 & 27 in observance of Thanksgiving. Deadline for the Nov. 26 issue of the Penny News will be 5 PM. Friday, Nov. 20.
KECO 96.5 FM's Santa's Christmas Heroes
KECO SANTAS HEROES

 

 

© Copyright 2026, Paragon Communications. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.